← Field notes
Field notes

When Sharks Attack Season 8 Premiere: “Hawaiian Night Fright”

This year, I had the pleasure to work on When Sharks Attack for NatGeo Channel, an investigatory series about shark attacks around the world. We filmed the premiere episode on location in Hawaii in Fall of 2021, and this episode is part of this year’s SharkFest event. Mark your calendars: “Hawaiian Night Fright” premieres Monday, July 11 on Nat Geo.

Here’s the mystery. The Kaiwi Channel between Molokai and Oahu is one of the toughest open-water swims on the planet: about 26 miles of deep, rough ocean, and most swimmers do it overnight. In 100 years, only seven shark bites had ever been recorded there. Then, in 2019, three marathon swimmers were bitten in less than five months. All three were in the water at night. All three came out with the same strange wound: a deep, perfectly round hole, like someone had taken an ice cream scoop to them.

A cookie-cutter sharkSomething was going on out there, and our episode sets out to figure out what.

The culprit turned out to be one of the weirdest animals I’ve ever had the chance to make TV about: the cookie-cutter shark. It tops out at about two feet long, which is not exactly Jaws. But it makes up for its size with a truly horrifying way of eating. It latches on with fleshy, suction-cup lips, sinks in a row of oversized lower teeth, then twists its body to carve out a neat, circular plug of flesh. Think of a toilet plunger with razor-sharp teeth. It usually does this to whales, tuna and dolphins, and they swim away with a souvenir scar. In 2019, it was doing it to people.

So how did a deep-sea shark end up biting swimmers? Cookie-cutters spend the day thousands of feet down in the dark, then migrate up toward the surface at night to feed. A swimmer crossing the channel after sundown is right in their dinner zone. To make it worse, a swimmer’s kicking and stroking can stir up the ocean’s bioluminescence, so every stroke lights up the water around them. To a hungry cookie-cutter, that glowing, splashing shape may look a lot like the big fish it’s looking for.

To crack the case, we worked with marine biologist Dr. Dan Huber of the University of Tampa, who studies how sharks bite. He compared the swimmers’ wounds against a 3D-printed model of a cookie-cutter shark’s jaw, and the match was unmistakable.

Filming on location in Hawaii was beautiful, but was also challenging – we filmed night time re-enactments on open water, with real channel swimmers, which was especially difficult. After learning all about cookie cutter sharks, I definitely didn’t jump into the water that night!

The good news: cookie-cutter bites are rare, and the swimmers in our episode survived and recovered. Channel swimmers are a unique type of badass athlete that are willing to put up with some pretty gnarly critters out in the ocean waters.

“Hawaiian Night Fright” is the Season 8 premiere of When Sharks Attack. It airs Monday, July 11 on Nat Geo, and it’ll stream on Disney+ and Hulu afterward. Tune in, then maybe wait until morning to go swimming.

Update: Nat Geo has posted the full episode on YouTube. Watch the full episode here: